16 / 17
Н.Н. Губанов, Н.И. Губанов, И.В. Денисова
16
Гуманитарный вестник
# 7·2017
The science of spatial localization of mental phenomena
© N.N. Gubanov
1
, N.I. Gubanov
2
, I.V. Denisova
2
1
Bauman Moscow State Technical University, Moscow, 105005, Russia
2
Tyumen State Medical University, Tyumen, 625023, Russia
The article presents criticism of the concept of personalism. According to the concept the
system of perceptive-objective activity and social relations serves as the immediate bear-
er of mental (psychic) phenomena. It is shown that brain neurodynamic systems are such
a bearer, and perceptive-objective activity is one of the conditions for the adequacy of
sensory cognition.
The weakness of the concept of extended psyche, widespread in Anglo-American philoso-
phy, is revealed. The supporters of the concept recognize the existence of mental phe-
nomena in the sign systems used by people now. It is substantiated that translational
codes as systems of external signs do not contain mental components and do not transfer
them, but cause the latter in subjects possessing sign meanings.
Keywords
: personalism, effector concept of the mental image, cerebralism, the concept of
the expanded psyche, translational codes, neurodynamic systems
REFERENCES
Tsaregorodtsev G.I., Shingarov G.H., Gubanov N.I.
Filosofiya
[Philosophy].
Moscow, Saratov State University Publ., 2012, 452 p.
Mc Dowel J.
Meaning, Knowledge and Reality
. Cambridge, Harvard Universi-
ty Press Publ., 2001, 478 p.
Bennet M., Hasker P.
Philosophical Foundations of Neuroscience
. Oxford,
Blackwel Publ., 2003, 480 p.
Bakhurst D.
Voprosy filosofii — The Problems of Philosophy
, 2013, no. 11,
pp. 50–65.
Mikhaylov F.T.
Zagadka chelovecheskogo Ya
[The riddle of the human self].
Moscow, Politizdat Publ., 1976, 288 p.
Lyubutin K., Pivovarov D.
Sinteticheskaya teoriya idealnogo
[Synthetic theory
of the ideal]. Ekaterinburg, Pskov, Pskov Regional Institute for Development
of Pedagogical Staff Publ., 2000, 207 p.
Leontev A.N.
Problemy razvitiya psikhiki
[Problems of mental evolution].
Moscow, Mysl Publ., 1965, 572 p.
Gubanov N.I., Gubanov N.N.
Vestnik Ishimskogo gosudarstvennogo pedago-
gicheskogo instituta im.P.P. Ershova — Bulletin of Yershov Ishim State Peda-
gogical Institute,
2014, no. 3, pp. 90–96.
Gubanov N.I., Gubanov N.N.
Voprosy filosofii — The Problems of Philosophy,
2015, no. 3, pp. 45–54.
Spirkin A.G.
Soznanie i samosoznanie
[Consciousness and self-awareness].
Moscow, Politizdat Publ., 1972, 303 p.
Ushakov G.K. Gallutsinatsii [Hallucinations]. In:
Bolshaya meditsinskaya
ehntsiklopediya. V 36 tomakh. Tom 4
[Great medical encyclopedia
.
In 36 vol-
umes. Vol. 4.] Moscow, Soviet Encyclopedia Publ., 1957, 562 p.
Gubanov N.I., Gubanov N.N.
Mentalnoe i fizicheskoe prostranstvo
[Mental
and physical space]. Moscow, International Publishing center “Etnosocium”
Publ., 2016, 144 p.
Clark A., Chalmers D.
Analisis,
1998, vol. 58 (1), pp. 7–19.